This is a splurge, but if there's one nursery item we'd be over the moon about, it's this chair! We are going to be spending a LOT of time in the nursery. It has smooth glide, slow power recline so you can recline while nap-trapped by sleeping baby, 180 degree swivel to reach items on the side table, and it's totally silent so it won't wake baby. It has stain-resistant and easy to clean fabric AND it's stylish enough that we would enjoy it in another room when baby reaches full-blown-kid age.
We need a rocking chair for the nursery, and this is one of the more affordable options. Good looking too!
Power Swivel Rocking Recliner - Cream Teddy
$609.99
Still needs 1
Gabriella Sleeveless Romper 3pc Set - 0/3M / oat linen
$24
Still needs 1
A shirt with a pouch so Matt can snuggle with baby hands-free. He is excited about this item.
Lalabu Dad Shirt - Short sleeve, Black
$89.95
Still needs 1
Model U® Horse Ride – Brown
$299
Still needs 1
Purchased
Found this one for 20% off on Rebel! Lightweight bouncer, easy to move around and take with you—they're a cozy place for your baby to play close by you while you have your hands free for a while. The natural rocking of a bouncer usually has a comforting effect on a very young baby. As your baby grows and learns how to control the rocking, the bouncer becomes even more fun and also stimulates your baby's balance and motor skills. Slipcover is washable.
(Used) BabyBjörn Bouncer Balance with Toy Bar - Beige
$184.99
Purchased
Soft and easy to wipe clean. Has a tuck-away toy bar with dangling toys to entertain baby. A safety belt and non-skid bottom keep the pad and baby secure during diaper changes.
Skip Hop Changing Pad (oat)
$67.99
Purchased
Trash can with extra-strength seal and air freshener to prevent the nursery from smelling like dirty diapers. Easy to use, large, has a foot-pedal for hands-free use.
Diaper Genie Platinum Diaper Trash Can (Lily White) i
$67.95
Purchased
Keeps baby wipes warm for comfortable diaper changes. Touchless open and has a night-light that turns on with a hand wave for middle-of-the-night changes.
Munchkin Touch Free Baby Wipe Warmer , White
$49.49
Purchased
Needed to block the bright nursery light, these are a high priority item. 30% less expensive than Pottery Barn or West Elm, but same look!
Linen True Blackout Curtain - Ivory, 48x84
$92
Purchased
On sale at Pottery Barn! Needed to hang blackout curtains in the nursery. We need 48-88" length, 0.75" diameter. Antique bronze matches our existing light fixtures. Note: rods and basic end-caps together are $158 per window.
Standard Curtain Rod & Wall Bracket, Antique Bronze - 48-88" long, 0.75" diam.
$158
Purchased
Babyletto
Gelato 3-Drawer Changer Dresser with Removable Changing Tray
$499
Purchased
These are the worlds softest blankets, and machine washable! Unbeatable quality. We have an adult size one and love it. The baby size is listed for $125, but you can ALWAYS find a discount code for 30-35% off (so $85-ish). Would be very nice for snuggling in the nursery glider, and then it can go on baby's crib/bed when she's older.
Lola Baby Blanket - Antique Ivory
$85
Purchased
Super easy to clean, and clean under (although Zoe will probably help with the latter). Converts to a toddler chair for continued functionality.
*Check Amazon before purchasing, may be cheaper with free shipping! (labeled Delta Summer Breeze Mattress there)We did a lot of research on baby mattresses and this seems like the best option. It has a firm and breathable infant side (needed for safety) but can be flipped to a softer toddler side that's more comfortable. Comes with waterproof cover and is anti-microbial and hypo-allergenic in case baby takes after Bailey (the allergy part we mean!).
Double Sided Infant/Toddler Mattress - Delta Children Breathe Mattress
$139.99
Purchased
30% off at Good-buy gear! Noise machines to help baby sleep at home and on the go. The larger Rest model also has programable light colors to teach toddlers when it's ok to get up and when they need to be in bed.
Hatch Rest & Hatch Go Sound Machine Bundle
$82.99
Purchased
45% off at GoodbuyGear! Super fast and large capacity bottle sterilizer and dryer takes only 10 min per cycle and holds 6 bottles plus miscellaneous small items like breast pump parts and pacifiers. White-on-white color preferred if still available.
Baby Brezza Superfast Bottle Sterilizer Dryer (White on White)
$89.99
Purchased
Simple, fast and effective. Warms breast milk and formula to the correct temperature without hot spots. Will be extra helpful when baby is sleeping upstairs so we don't need to trek downstairs for middle-of-the-night feedings.
Philips Avent Bottle Warmer
$49.95
Purchased
We will need a side table by the loft and nursery gliders to hold everything from phones to bottles.
Solid Wood Side Table
$146.99
Purchased
Whimsical forest scene overlaid with embroidery for a textured, heirloom-quality look. Goes with our dusty pink/apricot nursery color scheme without being overwhelmingly pink.
Convertible infant to toddler tub. The durable plastic tub has a mesh insert that can be fitted in one of three ways: as a hammock sling for newborns, a reclined support for 3- to 6-month-olds, and a bath seat with leg holes for older babies who can sit upright but need a little support. Seems practical and highly rated.
Frida Baby 4-in-1 Grow-with-Me Baby Bathtub
$49.97
Purchased
Super inexpensive from Wayfair, and would be perfect for the nursery! We need a ceiling light because the existing table lamps are moving upstairs with us into our new bedroom.
Semi Flush Mount Ceiling Light - Dark Bronze
$103.99
Purchased
Harlow Vegan Full - Terra brown
$189
Purchased
Stroller Hooks vegan Leather (terra brown)
$26
Purchased
Super soft and handy for the newborn stage. Comes highly recommended.
Solly Baby Wrap - Flax
$74
Purchased
This carrier comes highly recommended by both gear testers and friends. Design was revamped in 2025 to include easier strap adjustments with settings for both parents, softer mesh fabric, and storage for parent and baby needs.
Omni Deluxe Carrier - mesh, natural beige
$219
Purchased
We have heard rave reviews from friends about this smart bassinet. It detects motion and automatically soothes your baby to sleep. We found a local re-selling one and would love to grab it (they're $1,600 new - absurd!)
Cash fund
Snoo (used local)
$600
Purchased
Babyletto
Gelato 4-in-1 Convertible Crib with Toddler Bed Conversion Kit
$399
Purchased
HATCH Collection
Clean Beauty Belly Mini Me Oil for Stretch Marks
$28
Purchased
We love the Quinn organizer line and have several. This matches our nursery colors and would be perfect for keeping diaper change supplies within reach but tidy.
Pottery Barn Kids Quinn Diaper Organizer Tray
$79
Purchased
If you've ever been to our house you know it's cold in the winter (and even on summer mornings) and the nursery is the coldest room of all. This space heater can be set to keep the room at a specified temperature, and is touch/topple safe.
DREO Space Heater
$35.99
Purchased
If you've ever been to Teton Valley, you know it's quite dry. We don't have a humidifier, and this cool-mist one is baby-safe, compact and quiet.
Cool Mist Humidifier, 2.5L Tank
$27.95
Purchased
We love the Quinn line of organizers and have several already. Would love this stackable set to corral toys and stuffed animals in the nursery!
Pottery Barn Kids Quinn Stackable Bins, Set of 2 (white)
$169
Purchased
This would be perfect for the horse theme of our nursery!
Baby Mobile Horse and Clouds
$100
Purchased
We're re-purposing cute toys as the "decor" for the nursery. This pink abacus toy would be perfect!
Personalized Pink Abacus
$34.19
Purchased
KeaBabies 2-Pack Organic Crib Sheets - 52x28
$21.96
Purchased
Would love this in solid colors (sprout green, cream, baby blue, grey)
Magnetic Coverall
$28
Purchased
Silicone dots inside prevent these from coming off! Come highly recommended .
Squid Cloud Collection Socks (0-6 months)
$26
Purchased
Has fold-down cuffs to cover baby's feet and hands so socks/mittens are not needed! Would love solid colors (sprout green, baby blue, pink, cream)
Found this 27% off at Rebel!Award-winning infant play gym. Stage-based design that evolves with baby, facilitating developmental growth from newborn to toddler.Five distinct Montessori-inspired play zones aimed at healthy brain development, reducing overstimulation, and enhancing motor skills.